Crafted by Caitlin: Body Piercing & Cosmetic Tattooing

Tattoo shop in Columbus, Ohio

4.6
(89 reviews)
15 Price Ave #101, Columbus, OH 43201, USA
Columbus, Ohio 43201

Google lists this shop as PRICE_LEVEL_VERY_EXPENSIVE

Mad Rabbit Tattoo Balm
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases - Clicking Affiliate links helps me keep this site operational

More in Columbus
Browse every tattoo shop in Columbus or all tattoo shops in Ohio.

Customer Reviews

5 reviews

A
Amy Jones
Apr 2025

Just a warning to new customers: I had an appointment almost a year ago and just now decided to take my belly ring out because it became unbearable. Unfortunately it never healed and caused pain every day. I found out that I do not have the correct anatomy for a naval piercing and my body rejected it who knows how long ago. I always thought it was slightly off center too, even after Caitlin took the time to line it up. I could have avoided a permanent scar had I been told sooner. Not cute. Caitlin doesn't respond to texts regarding aftercare even though she encourages you to follow up with any questions. I got a third lobe piercing as well, which I think turned out fine, besides still being a little crusty. Overall Caitlin is a sweetheart and a very caring person but I can't help but question her expertise and precision given my experience.

M
Madison Decker
Apr 2025

The piercing went great, she was very friendly. The only issue is that she pierced my earlobes with a nose ring stud and neglected to tell me, and when I brought up it looked slightly tight she brushed it off and said it was slight swelling.

D
Dedrick Pitter
May 2023

Both my piercings by Caitlin were quick and easy. She was clear and concise about what to expect from the experience and how to care for and clean the piercings afterward. She was incredibly nice and professional and if I ever need piercings done again she’s the only one I’d go to. Highly recommended!

r
ryleigh meechan
May 2023

Caitlin is awesome! She did a septum piercing, conch piercing, and nipple piercings with ease and also did a lash enhancement tattoo for me! All of which healed beautifully with no problems at all! 10/10 recommend!!

L
Logan Clark
Mar 2023

Caitlin was so outgoing, comforting, professional and made me not as nervous for my navel piercing!! She did such a great job and I will definitely be returning!