Colt's Timeless Tattoos

4.7
(468 reviews)
2065 American Dr Suite C, Neenah, WI 54956
Neenah, Wisconsin 54956

Hours

Monday: 11 AM–7 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–7 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–7 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–7 PM
Friday: 11 AM–7 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–7 PM
Sunday: Closed

Features & Amenities

piercing

Piercing Services

service

Cover-Up Tattoos
Custom Tattoo Designs

artists

Guest Artists

booking

By Appointment Only

Customer Reviews

7 reviews

L
Laina Lutz
1 reviews
3 weeks ago

I had Mandy and first her set up is amazing so many horror elements and fun details that make long appointments so much fun just cool things to look at and movies to watch the whole time. She’s got amazing vibes and works to make you comfortable. The rest of the artists were kind and funny and lightened up the mood when I was struggling through the black out parts of my cover up. Mandy was able to cover my tattoo and make something beautiful despite the odd location and how dark the tattoo was previously. I am not embarrassed to wear short sleeves anymore and will be going back to her and the other artist even there for all my tattoos! Oh and also it’s so clean!!! (The picture is it immediately done before the shading was all complete. This was right after the first appointment and I’m excited to go back for the touch up on the shading ! )

A
April Coffey
4 reviews
3 weeks ago

My experience far exceeded my expectations! I can’t say enough great things about Danny. His attention to detail proves his dedication to his craft. My tribute tattoo turned out exactly as I had hoped for. I am fearful of needles. Danny took the time to explain everything. His patience helped to put me at ease. I highly recommend Danny!

D
Doug Ellerman
1 reviews
1 months ago

I have known Colt and his staff for more than a decade now. They are always professional and do great work. I am proud to call Colt a friend.

S
SHELLY Leurquin
8 reviews
1 months ago

I have had 2 piercings done by Abby now. Abby is awesome! She is very nice and helpful too!

J
Jean Jan (Jean)
6 reviews
1 months ago

Mandy is so good at what she does. Most recently, she added some flowers to my bracelet and the name of my newest grandchild. I’ll be going back early in 2026 for another name and touch up.

K
Kiana Herman
12 reviews
1 months ago

I will 100% always recommend Colts Timeless for any and all things tattoos and piercing related. I have gotten different tattoos from multiple artists there, more recently I got tattoos from Kade. Kade was wonderful, his artwork is detailed and he is a very comfortable and understanding person to speak with and get tattooed by. I am looking forward to my touch up soon with Kade. Abby has done pretty much every single piercing I have gotten. She is wonderful, kind, explanative when questions are asked and super fun to learn stories and knowledge from. The entire vibes of Colts Timeless is something I appreciate every time I walk in. From Danny cracking jokes, to seeing Colt working on tattoos or just actively walking by, to Ali (the front receptionist) being welcoming and helpful, to Kade's amazing talent and fun vibes and Amanda's AMAZING corner of horror; you literally cannot beat going here. If you are wondering about if you should go here, the answer is you should. Every. Single. Time.

M
M SC
32 reviews
1 months ago

You can go anywhere...but for the best ... In art, ink and passion...THIS is THE place to be. I cannot recommend them enough. Not enough *'s!